Noack Law Office
Free Initial Consultations

MN Supreme Court lets disability claim after workers' comp awarded

Some workplace injuries eventually heal completely. But it is common for an injured or sickened worker to never recover fully. Nevertheless, most work accident victims want to go back to work as soon as they are able. As with any disabled worker, survivors of workplace injuries in Minnesota are entitled to reasonable accommodations to allow them to do their jobs under the U.S. Americans With Disabilities Act and the state Human Rights Act.

There is obviously an intersection between workers’ compensation and employment law here. What if a person gets hurt on the job, receives workers’ compensation, and returns to work, only to be refused a reasonable accommodation by their employer? Could that person be entitled to an employment discrimination claim in addition to the workers’ comp relief?



New direction in Minnesota law

For decades, the answer in Minnesota was “no.” That has changed thanks to a recent decision by the state supreme court in favor of a Minneapolis firefighter whose request to wear sneakers at the station house was refused.

The firefighter was struggling with back problems. His doctor prescribed him to wear tennis shoes instead of standard firefighter boots, at least when not dealing with an emergency. But his superiors would not let him. He eventually received a $125,000 workers’ compensation settlement and retired.

He later filed a disability discrimination claim against the City of Minneapolis. The city argued that he was barred from making the claim based on a 30-year-old Minnesota Supreme Court decision that prohibits collecting twice for the same injury.

Discrimination claim allowed to proceed

But in a 5-2 ruling, the court ruled the man’s discrimination claim can proceed. “Unlike the workers’ compensation act,” Justice Margaret Chutich wrote in the decision, “the human rights act is a civil rights law that protects employees from unlawful employment discrimination.”

Talk to a Minnesota workers’ compensation attorney

Hopefully, if you get hurt at work, you will be able to go back to work someday without the sort of problems encountered by the man in this story. But first, you will likely need workers’ compensation benefits to help pay your medical bills and other expenses. A conversation with a workers’ comp attorney will help you understand the process.



No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information


A quick note to say thanks for your efforts in obtaining social security disability benefits for me.....My "life's journey" has had its bumps in the road, but things are starting to fall into place. - Satisfied client

Read More

Free Consultation | There Is Never A Fee Unless We Win

Our firm represents workers in the Minneapolis/St. Paul area and throughout the state of Minnesota. We will do depositions in your hometown, wherever that may be.

Contact Noack Law Office today at 952-467-8481 for a free consultation about your case. As our client, you do not have to worry about out-of-pocket expenses. You will not pay any fees unless and until you receive benefits.

Email Us For A Response

Questions? We Have Answers.

Contact the Firm

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Mound Office
4165 Shoreline Drive, Suite 20
Mound, MN 55384

Mound Law Office Map

Minneapolis Office
1515 East Lake Street
Suite 200
Mercado Central
Minneapolis, MN 55407

Minneapolis Law Office Map

St. Paul Office
925 Payne Avenue
Suite 201
La Plaza Latina
St. Paul, MN 55130

St. Paul Law Office Map